What I find strange is that it appears to me that if one brigade cannot afford it or don't think they need it because of a low call rate then why have it!
I come from a small brigade, with a low call rate (only about 40 calls a year, and not many of them during week day)s
As the Captain, I generally know who is around during week days - a few members work locally, one is retired, and there are a few shift workers and students - so I really only need to keep a track of around 7 people (which is also made easier because two of them live in my household!).
My members tell me when they are going away on holidays, or when they are on AL and around during the day.
So on any given weekday, I have a pretty good idea of who is around, and their skill levels.
At $60 per month, plus the internet connection that we don't currently have, the system is a very expensive way of telling me what I pretty much know already.
For busy brigades, with higher membership levels, higher calls rates and additional skill responsibilities (eg RCR, Hazmat etc) it is much harder to keep track of who is available, and what skill levels those responding have. A system that can quickly provide that information to the OIC can be useful.
This type of system, like may things in CFS, is not, and should not be, a one size fits all.
Pip