Ok, have read the thread from the link you provided. Still unclear about the issue, I'm not sure how a chat about fitness gets out of hand but I guess there is a discussion I have missed somewhere.
As I suggested in previous post, I think it would be worthwhile attaining a fitness standard for strike teams and deployments that mean climbing up and down hilly country dragging hoses, espeically if you come from a very flat region with only a few volcano bumps added just for interest
Problem as always is in how it is implemented, how fitness 'results' are used in the service, and indeed whether or not we even need to given that we may lose some volunteers over and the fact that Australia is full of Norms may not actually put our life at risk in a fire situation.
I guess that is the crux of the issue - 'Is fitness even an issue'? It's hard to link a lack of fitness with things like ankle injuries (better developed connective tissues from fitness may have prevented injury) and heat stress (better fitness leads to a greater ability to cope with such pressures on the body).
Personally, I think we'd all do better on the fireground if we simply were fully hydrated - pee in this cup prior to deployment - if it's dark yellow, you're a no go!